"The Play" - Eli Manning to David Tyree, NY Giants, Super Bowl XLII
Rick Nash Amazing Goal - Rick Nash, Columbus Blue Jackets, game winning goal with less than 30 seconds remaining
Trinity University Miracle - Trinity completes 15 laterals to win the game.
Blake Hoffarber Buzzer Beater - Minnesota upsets Indiana in Big Ten Tournament.
I would say Trinity has a shot if it weren't for the circumstances of the Super Bowl, no matter how catatonic Joe Buck sounds when calling the most amazing play in Super Bowl history. And the fact that a lot of defenders seemed to stop trying their hardest to stop them on that play. And that Nash goal is just plain filthy.