Right now - Payton Manning or Tom Brady

[Chubz]

Talent wise Im taking Payton......with a healthy Harrison that offense is every bit as good as New Englands

[Phistar]

i'm definitely taking manning, don't get me wrong... brady is good too, but manning is better

[Darius Ali]

Tom Brady. I just feel like he manages the game better. He makes less mistakes in my opinion. I always said that Tom Brady with WR's will put up the same stats as Manning. Well last year he had Moss ect and broke records. He throws a less amount of ints and is always calm. I know Manning won a Ring but I still tend to think he dissapears in big games. Even in that superbowl I think he threw 2 picks? This site is anti Tom Brady though so I expect lots of Hate for him. :)

[cruzg24]

Ill go with Brady on this one as well because he has lessened the gap number wise between both of them. They are both great QB's, its just that Brady has won more so its a slight advantage.

[Agent Zero]

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

This site is anti Tom Brady though so I expect lots of Hate for him. :)

LOL I have noticed that as well.

I chose Payton. Only because I really believe he is a student of the game. He, IMO is the most knowledgeable person in the NFL.(football smarts) And to be honest it wasn't an easy decision. Brady is just as good and at times looks better than Payton. Very tough choice...

[FSUViking]

Originally Posted by Chubz

Talent wise Im taking Payton......with a healthy Harrison that offense is every bit as good as New Englands

Yet Brady won 3 Super Bowl rings without Moss/Welker, and Manning has had Harrison the whole time and only has one, and that's because the Pats defense blew a lead, otherwise the scoreboard reads Brady 4, Manning 0. Head-to-head, Brady owns Manning. Brady's lost something like 3 postseason games in his life. Manning is .500 in the postseason.

Manning has his ring, and will probably have numerous records when it's all said and done, but Brady is on another level when the money is on the table. He's better under pressure and has done more with less his entire career. Brady has NEVER lost at home in the playoffs, while Manning has choked away 2 of the last 3 playoff games in the RCA Dome.

[Agent Zero]

Originally Posted by FSUViking

Yet Brady won 3 Super Bowl rings without Moss/Welker, and Manning has had Harrison the whole time and only has one, and that's because the Pats defense blew a lead, otherwise the scoreboard reads Brady 4, Manning 0. Head-to-head, Brady owns Manning. Brady's lost something like 3 postseason games in his life. Manning is .500 in the postseason.

Manning has his ring, and will probably have numerous records when it's all said and done, but Brady is on another level when the money is on the table. He's better under pressure and has done more with less his entire career. Brady has NEVER lost at home in the playoffs, while Manning has choked away 2 of the last 3 playoff games in the RCA Dome.

While I agree with this to a degree. I have one word for you my friend....

COACHING

[Darius Ali]

What does that mean? You trying to say that Dungy can't coach?

[HolySchnikes]

Right now on this day i'd take Tom Brady. we all saw what he did last year when he had talented WRs around him and we've seen him play without those WRs and was still good. Peyton Manning has never had to worry anout not having a WR, because he's had Harison his whole career and now he will finish his career with Wayne. i like Manning better than Brady, but on this day i'd take Brady.

[jstchilln120]

As much as I hate to say it, I'd have to pick Tom Brady. Why? Because the one knock on him has always been that he can't put up big stats and lead a juggernaut passing offense. Well, he sure proved that this season.

If he's as talented a passer with a number of weapons at the WR/TE positions and has the ability to manage games and win SBs with less talent, you have to give him the nod.

[Chubz]

Originally Posted by jstchilln120

As much as I hate to say it, I'd have to pick Tom Brady. Why? Because the one knock on him has always been that he can't put up big stats and lead a juggernaut passing offense. Well, he sure proved that this season.

If he's as talented a passer with a number of weapons at the WR/TE positions and has the ability to manage games and win SBs with less talent, you have to give him the nod.

At the same time, Payton if he had Harrison last year..who knows. I'll take the Colts offense whith everyone healthy over the Pats. I can't see Moss duplicating last season at all.

[P J Shaker]

im taking manning....if you put moss on the the colts manning has 60 TD passes...

plus manning is more dependable..i mean Brady has been on the injured list for 3 years with that leg or shoulder injury...HAHAH