In their prime Montana vs. Brady

[Agent Zero]

If it was the Super Bowl and both QB's were in there prime and you had to choose one to lead your team to victory who would you choose?

I say Montana all the way!! Mr. Clutch is what I call him. Montana never froze and always found a way to win.

What says you???

[P J Shaker]

i would say Brady for the only reason that he never had a jerry rice type untill this year.....Brady made all of his receivers before...and when they left, they sucked

[nyG]

well the Giants destroyed both once in the playoffs.

But you say in their prime so I have to take Montana. 4 Rings, 3 Supe MVPs, plus bouncing back from injuries to still be productive. Joe is the king of clutch football.

[P J Shaker]

joe was also good untill the day he retired...even in KC he was still a good QB

[Darius Ali]

The Giants destroyed Brady and the Pats? I don't remember that.

Anyways, its so damn tough but give me Brady.

[Chubz]

the giants destroyed the pats offensive line which was considered almost inpregnable

[Agent Zero]

Originally Posted by Chubz

the giants destroyed the pats offensive line which was considered almost inpregnable

Hey.. Don't jack my thread.. Back on topic damnit.

[Darius Ali]

I suppose. But they didn't destroy the Pats overall. Anyways, Tom and Joe are just too close to call honestly. Montana is like the god of QB's so Tom can be Jesus.

[Agent Zero]

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

Montana is like the god of QB's so Tom can be Jesus.

LMAO!! That is funny.. Great comparison..

[nyG]

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

I suppose. But they didn't destroy the Pats overall. Anyways, Tom and Joe are just too close to call honestly. Montana is like the god of QB's so Tom can be Jesus.

I never said AND the Pats. G-Men destroyed both QBs. In the 86 playoffs, en route to their 1st Super Bowl, Jim Burt knocked Montana out of the game during the divisional round. In the 90 playoffs, Leonard Marshall sacked Joe, knocking out of the game, the whole 91 season, and half of the 92 season. This ignited the beginning of the Steve Young era.

and as well all know in Supe 42, Brady was sacked 5 times, and hit many many more times. He was abused all day.

Wouldn't Steve Young have to be Jesus if Montana were God?

[Darius Ali]

Brady is better then Young. But Young is another great one. Top ten in my book.

[P J Shaker]

yea its not every day you have a hall of famer leave and then have another one come in after him