Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb - The Postgame Pub

**cruzg24** · 09-16-2008, 02:54 PM

Which one do you take? 2 have been to the Super Bowl, and the other is a young up and comer.

I take the hardware and go with Manning on this one.

**Chubz** · 09-16-2008, 03:06 PM

thisis tough because Manning's regular season stats are pitifull. If Manning plays like the Manning we are seeing now (the manning we also saw in the playoffs), ill take Manning. Manning was clutch in the playoffs, making the right throws and it's carried over. Thats why I take Manning. Romo still has alot more to prove than just being a regualr season Queen.

Also remember this, no combo over the last 4 years has more TD's than Manning/Burress. I think Eli's problem was jeremy shockey to be honest. Manning has all the weapons now for him to succed and not have to try and win games by forcing the ball downfield every play.

dmoney3 · 09-16-2008, 03:20 PM

I agree with Chubz., Manning has proved himself in the playoffs. Up to this point Romo has done nothing but choke in the playoffs. I like Romo, but he needs to carry his regular season play to the playoffs.

**cruzg24** · 09-16-2008, 03:29 PM

Wow you guys aren't even talking about Mcnabb who carries the Eagles on his back every year....

**nyG** · 09-16-2008, 03:32 PM

wrong, that job belongs to Westbrook.

Darius Ali · 09-16-2008, 03:54 PM

For now, I'll go with Romo-Manning-McNabb. But Manning is really closing that gap. If he puts together a entire season thats consistent he will prob be a top 3-4 QB with the dropoff of Carson Palmer so far. I wonder if that injury Palmer had to his knee changed him forever.

**cruzg24** · 09-16-2008, 04:00 PM

No Way, before Westbrook got there. Mcnabb was the Eagles. And he still is, he is a great QB and is overshadowed for some odd reason. And I really don't give a crap what Romo does for the rest of his career until he proves he can win a big game, by not making dumb mistakes; like botching a kick for his team.

dmoney3 · 09-16-2008, 04:12 PM

Reason we are not talking about Mcnab is because he hasnt proven himself by staying healthy for a full season. Last three seasons he has missed a lot of games. Also I just cant see the Eagles in the superbowl. I dont believe he can get them there. Westbrook is the star of the eagles

dmoney3 · 09-16-2008, 04:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

For now, I'll go with Romo-Manning-McNabb. But Manning is really closing that gap. If he puts together a entire season thats consistent he will prob be a top 3-4 QB with the dropoff of Carson Palmer so far. I wonder if that injury Palmer had to his knee changed him forever.

How can you have Romo on top?????. He cant prove himself when January rolls around. Manning has a ring on his finger. Hes gotta be number 1 for now. Also his play so far this year has been great.

Darius Ali · 09-16-2008, 04:22 PM

If Romo chokes in the playoffs this season then I'll give the nod to Eli. But Romo has been very consistent for the past few years and is doing it again this year. Eli has been borderline awful outside of 4 playoff games.

Stop being a Manning Homer! Colts fan. Haha.

Brandy gave me your number so I'll call again soon man.

**Chubz** · 09-16-2008, 07:38 PM

Wat to know what sperates Manning from Romo for me? The drive manning made against the Cowboys in the playoffs before halftime. Marched them down field in what under a minute? I think theres a point in alot of players career, whether they are heralded or not....when they make a turn. I think That happened over the second half of last year and is continuing for Manning right now. To be blunt about it, he looks like his brother. Lots of poise, making the right throw and not forcing anything. He's a very confident QB right now, and thats the most dangerous type in the NFL.

dmoney3 · 09-16-2008, 11:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

If Romo chokes in the playoffs this season then I'll give the nod to Eli. But Romo has been very consistent for the past few years and is doing it again this year. Eli has been borderline awful outside of 4 playoff games.

Stop being a Manning Homer! Colts fan. Haha.

Brandy gave me your number so I'll call again soon man.

Manning homer lol Nah I think Eli finally came around. Yeah give me a ring this weekend bro. We have a lot to catch up on

**SouthernWebb04** · 09-17-2008, 01:51 AM

Maybe this topic should be changed. It doesn't say 'in the regular season' or 'in the playoffs'

But, it's pretty easy for me.

Regular Season - Romo
Post-Season - McNabb

He was one hurt leg from driving the Eagles back against the Pats, and without T.O. had to make everything else work to get them into that Superbowl. Eli is chomping at the bit on that though.

09-16-2008, 02:54 PM	#1 (permalink)
cruzg24 PGP Moderator Join Date: May 2008 Location: New York Posts: 2,674 vCash: 32282 Donate My Blog: Frontpage Stardom PSN Gamertag: cruztoro24 Blog Entries: 10 Rep Power: 58 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb Which one do you take? 2 have been to the Super Bowl, and the other is a young up and comer. I take the hardware and go with Manning on this one. __________________

09-16-2008, 03:06 PM	#2 (permalink)
Chubz The Human Steamroller Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Toms River, NJ Posts: 5,716 vCash: 3607 Donate My Blog: The Chubzone XBL Gamertag: xXchubbzillaXx PSN Gamertag: Chubzilla Blog Entries: 3 Rep Power: 100 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb thisis tough because Manning's regular season stats are pitifull. If Manning plays like the Manning we are seeing now (the manning we also saw in the playoffs), ill take Manning. Manning was clutch in the playoffs, making the right throws and it's carried over. Thats why I take Manning. Romo still has alot more to prove than just being a regualr season Queen. Also remember this, no combo over the last 4 years has more TD's than Manning/Burress. I think Eli's problem was jeremy shockey to be honest. Manning has all the weapons now for him to succed and not have to try and win games by forcing the ball downfield every play. __________________

09-16-2008, 03:20 PM	#3 (permalink)
dmoney3 PGP Batboy Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Alaska Posts: 25 vCash: 1116 Donate Rep Power: 1	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb I agree with Chubz., Manning has proved himself in the playoffs. Up to this point Romo has done nothing but choke in the playoffs. I like Romo, but he needs to carry his regular season play to the playoffs.

09-16-2008, 03:29 PM	#4 (permalink)
cruzg24 PGP Moderator Join Date: May 2008 Location: New York Posts: 2,674 vCash: 32282 Donate My Blog: Frontpage Stardom PSN Gamertag: cruztoro24 Blog Entries: 10 Rep Power: 58 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb Wow you guys aren't even talking about Mcnabb who carries the Eagles on his back every year.... __________________

09-16-2008, 03:54 PM	#6 (permalink)
Darius Ali PGP HoFer Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Cheyenne, Wyoming Posts: 2,616 vCash: 29888 Donate My Blog: BallAboveAll-Basketball news and analysis PSN Gamertag: DariusJustinAli Blog Entries: 5 Rep Power: 56 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb For now, I'll go with Romo-Manning-McNabb. But Manning is really closing that gap. If he puts together a entire season thats consistent he will prob be a top 3-4 QB with the dropoff of Carson Palmer so far. I wonder if that injury Palmer had to his knee changed him forever. __________________ "Just Win Baby"

09-16-2008, 04:00 PM	#7 (permalink)
cruzg24 PGP Moderator Join Date: May 2008 Location: New York Posts: 2,674 vCash: 32282 Donate My Blog: Frontpage Stardom PSN Gamertag: cruztoro24 Blog Entries: 10 Rep Power: 58 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb No Way, before Westbrook got there. Mcnabb was the Eagles. And he still is, he is a great QB and is overshadowed for some odd reason. And I really don't give a crap what Romo does for the rest of his career until he proves he can win a big game, by not making dumb mistakes; like botching a kick for his team. __________________

09-16-2008, 04:12 PM	#8 (permalink)
dmoney3 PGP Batboy Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Alaska Posts: 25 vCash: 1116 Donate Rep Power: 1	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb Reason we are not talking about Mcnab is because he hasnt proven himself by staying healthy for a full season. Last three seasons he has missed a lot of games. Also I just cant see the Eagles in the superbowl. I dont believe he can get them there. Westbrook is the star of the eagles

09-16-2008, 04:22 PM	#10 (permalink)
Darius Ali PGP HoFer Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: Cheyenne, Wyoming Posts: 2,616 vCash: 29888 Donate My Blog: BallAboveAll-Basketball news and analysis PSN Gamertag: DariusJustinAli Blog Entries: 5 Rep Power: 56 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb If Romo chokes in the playoffs this season then I'll give the nod to Eli. But Romo has been very consistent for the past few years and is doing it again this year. Eli has been borderline awful outside of 4 playoff games. Stop being a Manning Homer! Colts fan. Haha. Brandy gave me your number so I'll call again soon man. __________________ "Just Win Baby"

09-16-2008, 07:38 PM	#11 (permalink)
Chubz The Human Steamroller Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Toms River, NJ Posts: 5,716 vCash: 3607 Donate My Blog: The Chubzone XBL Gamertag: xXchubbzillaXx PSN Gamertag: Chubzilla Blog Entries: 3 Rep Power: 100 Awards Showcase Total Awards: 2	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb Wat to know what sperates Manning from Romo for me? The drive manning made against the Cowboys in the playoffs before halftime. Marched them down field in what under a minute? I think theres a point in alot of players career, whether they are heralded or not....when they make a turn. I think That happened over the second half of last year and is continuing for Manning right now. To be blunt about it, he looks like his brother. Lots of poise, making the right throw and not forcing anything. He's a very confident QB right now, and thats the most dangerous type in the NFL. __________________

09-17-2008, 01:51 AM	#13 (permalink)
SouthernWebb04 You Want It, I Got It Join Date: Jun 2008 Location: Dallas, TX Posts: 381 vCash: 2767 Donate XBL Gamertag: SouthernDip Blog Entries: 2 Rep Power: 8	Re: Eli Manning vs. Tony Romo vs. Donovan Mcnabb Maybe this topic should be changed. It doesn't say 'in the regular season' or 'in the playoffs' But, it's pretty easy for me. Regular Season - Romo Post-Season - McNabb He was one hurt leg from driving the Eagles back against the Pats, and without T.O. had to make everything else work to get them into that Superbowl. Eli is chomping at the bit on that though. __________________ TotalSportsWorld.net The Number One Sports Sim Community

09-17-2008, 12:13 PM	#14 (permalink)
cruzg24 PGP Moderator Join Date: May 2008 Location: New York Posts: 2,674