Sportingnews.com ranks the top 25 QB in the NFL - Page 2 - Sports Forum - Baseball, Football, Basketball and Off Topic Discussion Forums

**Chubz** · 07-16-2008, 02:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

I'd take Romo over Big Ben or Hasselbeck in a second.

I'd take Ben over Romo. Ben won a superbowl

**P J Shaker** · 07-16-2008, 02:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chubz

I'd take Ben over Romo. Ben won a superbowl

so did Brad Johnson and Trent Dilfer...i wouldnt have taken either of them over romo...even in their primes

Darius Ali · 07-16-2008, 02:54 PM

Your right PJ. BEN didn't win that superbowl. The TEAM did. He actually played horrible IN that game too. Romo is more skilled then Ben IMO. People put too much stock into superbowl wins I think. Dan Marino doesnt have a ring but he is a billion times better then Ben.

**Chubz** · 07-16-2008, 02:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

Your right PJ. BEN didn't win that superbowl. The TEAM did. He actually played horrible IN that game too. Romo is more skilled then Ben IMO.

and tell me that Romo played well in the playoff game last year? That was Ben's rookie season that he took his team to the SB. A team that went 10-6 and he had a good season too.

ZCHF · 07-16-2008, 02:56 PM

Are you guys kidding me. Romo has a much better line and weapons then Ben and still hasn't accompished at much. BB over Romo everyday of the week.

Number 2 in passer rating last year for Christ's sake

ZCHF · 07-16-2008, 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chubz

and tell me that Romo played well in the playoff game last year? That was Ben's rookie season that he took his team to the SB. A team that went 10-6 and he had a good season too.

Actually that was his second season

His first he went undefeated in the regular season and lost in the Champ game to NE...

**P J Shaker** · 07-16-2008, 03:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chubz

and tell me that Romo played well in the playoff game last year? That was Ben's rookie season that he took his team to the SB. A team that went 10-6 and he had a good season too.

i will add to your argument also...ben won every playoff game on the road too....and he did have great poise for being a rookie....but since then i really think Ben has lost something...he just doesnt seem to be the player he was that year...i think the motorcycle had something to do with that...but i can say last year he did show alot of signs of improvements.....if you ask me in like 2 years i might say Ben if he keeps comming back they way he is...but for right now i would say Romo (and i dont really like romo)

Darius Ali · 07-16-2008, 03:07 PM

Ben didn't have to pass but 15 times MAYBE a game those first two seasons. They relied on the run game on thier great defense to win ball games.

**Chubz** · 07-16-2008, 03:07 PM

what has Romo shown? Sexy regular season numbers last year?

**P J Shaker** · 07-16-2008, 03:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chubz

what has Romo shown? Sexy regular season numbers last year?

he shows alot of potential...last year stats

...............Rating......Yards...... TD's..... INT...... SACKs...... CMP%
Romo - ......97.4...... ..4,211 .......36........19..........24...........64.4
Big Ben - ...104.1........3,154........32........11......... .47...........65.3

the numbers arent to far apart...but yards, td's and times sacked favor romo pretty well....the only thing that Ben has a clear advantage on is Int's..

**Agent Zero** · 07-16-2008, 03:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chubz

what has Romo shown? Sexy regular season numbers last year?

Don't hate.. Romo had a good game in the playoffs. It was the team that let him down. Now I am not saying Romo is top 5 (yet) but give credit were credit is due.

ZCHF · 07-16-2008, 03:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Darius Ali

Ben didn't have to pass but 15 times MAYBE a game those first two seasons. They relied on the run game on thier great defense to win ball games.

That's not his fault...that was all he needed to do to win, and he did a damn good job at it. What about last year...what about his 3000 + yards and 32 TD's...what about his 104 passer rating?

Quote:

Originally Posted by P J Shaker

he shows alot of potential...last year stats

...............Rating......Yards...... TD's..... INT...... SACKs...... CMP%
Romo - ......97.4...... ..4,211 .......36........19..........24...........64.4
Big Ben - ...104.1........3,154........32........11......... .47...........65.3

the numbers arent to far apart...but yards, td's and times sacked favor romo pretty well....the only thing that Ben has a clear advantage on is Int's..

You what that tells me?

1) Dallas is a pass first run second team
2) Dallas has a better passing OLine
3) BB is a better QB(Passer Rating, TD's/Int, Comp %...and so on)